bribery and corruption in business ethics

ISSN 0167-4544 Full text not available from this repository. We all have a responsibility to combat bribery in global business. Gift Giving, Bribery and Corruption: Ethical Management of Business Relationships in China P. Steidlmeier Gift giving is a prevalent social custom in China in all areas of life: in family and in significant relationships (guanxi), as well as in dealing with political authorities, social institutions and business people. corporate bribery Business ethics and anti-corruption Asia Pacific insights Financial institutions Energy Infrastructure, mining and commodities Transport Technology and innovation Life sciences and healthcare. What happens when cultures change but business practices don’t? Today there are still business gift-giving occasions in Japan, specifically oseibo (year’s end) and ochugen (midsummer). Cultures that have clear guidelines for right and wrong behavior may see this situation differently than a culture in which doing favors is part of the normal practice. Organisations of all sizes and industries should take steps now to ensure that they don’t end up on a future list of top bribery and corruption scandals. According to the survey, asset misappropriation fraud is the most disruptive to Philippine businesses, with at least 26 percent or one out of four businesses having experienced it since 2018. A company may declare this inappropriate behavior, but employees may still do what they think is best for their jobs. It creates a huge distortion in the appropriation of human and financial resources to ineffective uses. The present company was founded in 1847 in Berlin and is now headquartered in Munich, Germany. Companies and their employees routinely try to balance ethical behavior with business interests. Bribery and corruption is a way of life in many countries. The police are cited as being the most frequent recipient of bribes, according to those surveyed. This paper will focus on the analysis of the well-known and popular bribery scandal in the world, such as Siemens AG Bribery Scandal which occurred in November, 2006. Corruption in business involves misappropriation of funds, bribery, misuse of office by company officials and dishonesty in financial matters. The following is an excerpt from their 2010 Global Corruption Barometer report, which captures the experiences and views of 91,500 people in 86 countries and territories: “Corruption has increased over the last three years,” say six out of ten people around the world. I have then been asked to assess these social implications of business ethics. However, since 2013 the PRC government has initiated a new, comprehensive anti-corruption campaign, targeted indiscriminately at officials, state-owned enterprises, and domestic and foreign private companies. The Code sets out a zero tolerance policy towards bribery, fraud, theft and other … As the Department of Justice continues to investigate the business practices of some of the largest companies in the world, it is likely that more evidence of bribery and corruption will be found. The practice of using connections to advance business interests exists in just about every country in the world. New laws and agreements are in place as part of an international effort to eliminate corruption and bribery from international business and ensure that competition is fair and open. Those involved in business settings apply ethics to business situations, known as business ethics. Connections are considered essential for success. In Asia, gift giving is so ingrained in the culture, particularly in Japan and China, that it is formalized and structured. Social implications of business ethics Ochugen usually occurs in mid-July in Tokyo and mid-August in some other regions. Bribery and corruption and then lastly customer fraud,” he said. In some cultures, there may be conflicts with global business practices, such as in the area of gift giving, which has evolved into bribery—a form of corruption. There are still global firms that engage in questionable business gift giving; when caught, they face fines and sanctions. In the United States and other similar countries, professionals prefer to imply that they have achieved success on their own merits and without any connections. Say no toolkit - from the Institute of Business Ethics; Report bribery and corruption. In India and Mexico, for example, a grease payment may help get your phones installed faster—at home or at work. Therefore, much care is given to the appropriateness of the gift as well as to its aesthetic beauty. This is a good opportunity to thank clients for their business. Long an established form of relationship development in all business conducted in Asia, the Arab world, and Africa, gift giving was clearly tipping over into outright bribery. Paying bribes is relatively common in many countries, and bribes often take the form of grease payments, which are small inducements intended to expedite decisions and transactions. There is a particular framework businesses are to follow. There is an established price level that one should pay for each corporate level. Business Ethics and Anti-Corruption Why are business ethics and anti- corruption important? This guides our approach to ethical conduct, as do our dedicated principles and standards, including our Code of Conduct. Oseibo gifts are presented in the first half of December as a token of gratitude for earlier favors and loyalty. Because bribery is bad for business, I work on sane, cost-effective compliance solutions to the problem of international commercial corruption. Our Business Ethics Policy is central to this. This level of corruption became more apparent in the 1980s as transparency in global business gained media attention. Airbus to pay record £3bn to settle bribery and corruption probes. According to the Electronic Journal of Business Ethics and Organizational Studies (2006), corruption is an economic problem intertwined with politics. News Business Business News. Unless companies ‘conform’ to such practices, in many cases, international business cannot be transacted. These are must-give occasions for Japanese businesses. Bribery and corruption disrupt the normal public policy decision making and typical business running by benefitting fewer citizens at the expense of the larger majority. Yet corrupt practices are a part of the ‘culture’ of ‘doing businesses. Even the most respected of global companies has found itself on the wrong side of the ethics issue and the law. Some may view bribery and corruption as financial crimes, with no apparent victims. However, business do not have to involve none of them. Eight out of ten say political parties are corrupt or extremely corrupt, while half the people questioned say their government’s action to stop corruption is ineffective. In the past twelve months one in four people reported paying a bribe to one of nine institutions and services, from health to education to tax authorities. Abstract Business ethics is a form of professional ethics or applied ethics that examines moral or ethical problems that arise in a business enviroment. These practices affect the way international business is regularly conducted. Some people consider it to be a fair business tactic, others consider it to be an unethical act. About 30 percent of those who had contact with the police reported having paid a bribe. Until governments in every country consistently monitor and enforce anticorruption laws, bribery will remain a real and very challenging issue for global businesses. Code of Ethics - Anti corruption and bribery . It involves the application of moral behavior to business situations (Adeyeye, 2012 p 22). The biggest increases were in Chile, Colombia, Kenya, FYR Macedonia, Nigeria, Poland, Russia, Senegal and Thailand. Yet corrupt practices are a part of the ‘culture’ of ‘doing businesses. Corruption and bribery in Nordics. Bribery in business ethics includes Selection of weak design or bad performance material vendor to get any sort of kickbacks. However, the extent and manner in which it is institutionalized differs from culture to culture. Corruption often results in loss of funds through embezzlement and graft. Scope. Bribery, on the other hand, is more commonly considered the practice in which an individual would benefit with little or no benefit to the company. Most worrying is the fact that bribes to the police have almost doubled since 2006, and more people report paying bribes to the judiciary and for registry and permit services than five years ago. Does that behavior become unethical, and is the person engaged in the behavior unethical? Companies must be aware of ethical standards and acceptable behavior. Asians tend to take a very different view of accountability than most Westerners. What may be acceptable at certain points in history, such as racism or sexism, became unacceptable with the further development of society’s mind-set. ‘Their actions were not an anomaly,’ said Joseph Persichini Jr., the head of the Washington office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. There are still countless less visible gestures that some would argue are also unethical. Considering bribery to simply be a necessary evil or the way business is done are attitudes that become deeply ingrained in people and are difficult to purge. Furthermore, the researcher will identify business practices that are considered illegal and unethical in the United States and address why these same practices are considered legal and ethical in, what to do in certain situations, ethics is what guides an individual to act in a way that is good, or right. A corrupt company is likely to violate ethical … Besides, internal or external corruption may force a company to inflate its prices so as to recover lost resources. While corruption is now widely viewed as unethical, firms still lose business to companies that may be less diligent in adhering to this principle. Views on corruption were most negative in Western Europe and North America, where 73 percent and 67 percent of people, respectively, thought corruption had increased over the last three years. For example, imagine that an employee works at a firm that wants to land a contract in China. This is not considered bribery in business, but simply the giving of gifts to sway customers to a business deal. This awareness means that marketers must recognize the viewpoints of three key players: the company, the industry, and society. The Commonwealth Criminal Code in Australia and the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act in the United States prohibit offering anything of value to foreign officials for improperly influencing a decision. From the editor I am delighted to bring to you this eighth issue of Business ethics and anti-corruption: Asia Pacific Insights. The mining industry operates in a complex and demanding legal and regulatory environment under cyclical market conditions. Journal of Business Ethics . This article first states the, Running Head: INTERNATIONAL MARKETING ETHICS Corruption is “giving or obtaining advantage through means which are illegitimate, immoral, and/or inconsistent with one’s duty or the rights of others.”. Bribery, usually in the form of a cash payment, has reached such high proportions in some countries that even locals express disgust with the corruption and its impact on daily life for businesses and consumers. Sports is another arena in which bribery and corruption commonly occur. This is a gray area of global business ethics. Social implication is a term used to describe the actions of a business that will have an impact on society, With Corporate Bribery Bribery in Business. Four Articles They accounted for … “Officials said that Siemens, beginning in the mid-1990s, used bribes and kickbacks to foreign officials to secure government contracts for projects like a national identity card project in Argentina, mass transit work in Venezuela, a nationwide cell phone network in Bangladesh, and a United Nations oil-for-food program in Iraq under Saddam Hussein. To begin our discussion of corruption, let’s first define it in a business context. Bribery and corruption are commonly though of in relation to politics and governmental corruption. Bribery is an intricate malpractice that can be carried out in various ways. ISO 37001 Anti-Bribery Management Systems standard provides a comprehensive approach to mitigating bribery and corruption risk. It involves the application of moral behavior to business situations (Adeyeye, 2012 p 22). Most people agree that bribery in any form only increases the cost of doing business—a cost that is either absorbed by the company or eventually passed on to the buyer or consumer in some form. The Code of Business Ethics is signed off by the OMV Executive Board. Resources that could be useful in implementing business strategies are derailed or used unproductively. Sadly, few people trust their governments or politicians. (“Sabancı Holding”). Such is to prohibit acts of bribery and corruption,and mandate that STRAITS Group establishes and maintain adequate procedures to prevent bribery and corruption. Publication type: Business ethics briefing. In contrast, Asian, Latin American, and Middle Eastern cultures are quick to value connections and relationships and view gifts quite positively. Business Ethics and Anti Corruption. “Public engagement in the fight against corruption will force those in authority to act—and will give people further courage to speak out and stand up for a cleaner, more transparent world.”[1]. The mining industry operates in a complex and demanding legal and regulatory environment under cyclical market conditions. What you can expect from us: We will not participate in any form of corrupt behaviour, either directly or indirectly, anywhere in the world. Investigating the ethics of bribery in places where the practice is common. What’s Nordic corruption (Nordic Business Ethics Corruption study 2020) Legislative framework for anti-corruption; How to fight corruption in practice. Businesses, business schools, and governments are increasingly making efforts to deter firms and professionals from making and taking bribes. More than twenty countries have reported significant increases in petty bribery since 2006. Gift giving in the global business world is used to establish or pay respects to a relationship. In 2016, the Institute of Business E… While the media covers stories of firms that have breached this ethical conduct, the misconduct of many more companies goes undetected. Our governance procedures are centered around our Code of Business Ethics. Examples include the 1997 OECD Convention, the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA), the UK Bribery Act (UKBA), the French anticorruption law and the China Anti Unfair Competition Law. Since these three groups almost always have different needs and, Congress enacted the FCPA to bring a halt to the bribery of foreign officials and to restore public confidence in the integrity of the American business system. Let's work together to do our part. The vice can be perpetuated by an individual or a clique of employees within a business organization. Despite these guidelines, gift giving in Japan has occasionally crossed over into bribery. Business relationships rely on trust. Social implications (P3) Prevention methods for unethical practice have to be carried out by engineers and the importance of upholding the professionalism in engineering field has to be kept in mind in order to create an honorable, responsible, ethical and lawful profession. But corruption means that public money may be diverted from helping the most vulnerable in society, power is abused and infrastructure suffers. Among other things, it reduces uncertainty for employees when under pressure to pay or accept a bribe and helps to create a more stable business environment with positive reputational effects in the long term. Bribery - means giving or receiving an unearned reward to influence someone's behaviour. Recent UK legislation expands the scope of bribery to include business to business extortion and kickbacks. Each year Transparency International analyzes trends in global corruption. For example, gift giving in Japan was for centuries an established practice in society and is still taken seriously. There is no express defence of adequate anti-bribery compliance procedures under key anti-corruption laws in the PRC. The prevalence of corrupt practices and in particular bribery is increasing adding significant costs to business. In a business ethics situation, the Foreign Corruption Practices Act would prohibit offering any bribe to the custom office – for example to free a shipment of goods that was lost in red tape (Pitman & Sanford, 2006). Competing firms can seize this opportunity to outdo the affected firm, leading to a significant decline in … It is the misuse of one’s office position for personal benefit. Corruption occurs in many contexts and institutions, including government, the military, and even religious institutions. A key government official in China finds out that you went to the business school that his daughter really wants to attend. BUSINESS ETHICS, BRIBERY AND CORRUPTION 3 Moral Issues in Business 3rd Edition Asia-Pacific Bribery is the act of receiving or issuing something valuable for the influence of getting something or exchange of an action. On the other hand, corruption means soliciting or offering significant value to change activities or influence decisions in place of power or authority. The FCPA was intended to have (and has had) an enormous impact on the way American firms do business. All four articles center their focus on business ethics. Of the four articles, three are scholarly peer-reviewed journal articles and one, by Friedman, is an online periodical. The first article is “To be ethical or not to be: An international code of ethics for leadership” by Aja Alahmad. Poorer people are twice as likely to pay bribes for basic services, such as education, than wealthier people. Commonly, people confused business, Corruption Within the Criminal Justice System, Features of Charismatic Leadership: Mahathir Mohamad, The Economic Impact of Rising Oil Prices in Automotive Industry. The discussion and the proper analysis of this bribery scandal will help to learn many effective lessons. The business organisation I have chosen for this assignment is ‘Boots’. Poor business ethics include bribery, corporate accounting scandals, and, the topic of social responsibility and business ethics before concluding the paper. Subsea 7 Group has an anti-bribery / anti-corruption (ABAC) compliance and ethics programme designed to prevent bribery and corruption by the company, its officers and employees, and any person who works for us or provides services for or on our behalf. In conclusion, engineers should always take consideration and action according to the codes of ethics. In Western countries, connections are viewed informally and sometimes even with a negative connotation. 389) and it can help unify an organization under one set of ethical conduct, Introduction On the other hand, corruption means soliciting or offering significant value to change activities or influence decisions in place of power or authority. In a business ethics situation, the Foreign Corruption Practices Act would prohibit offering any bribe to the custom office – for example to free a shipment of goods that was lost in red tape (Pitman & Sanford, 2006). Most companies also have policies against bribery as well. Both the key anti-corruption laws of Japan have extraterritorial effect. “The fallout of the financial crises continues to affect people’s opinions of corruption, particular in North America and Western Europe. The Hargreaves Services plc reputation is built on our values as a company, the values of our employees, and our collective commitment to acting at all times with integrity. In some cultures, there may be conflicts with global business practices, such as in the area of gift giving, which has evolved into bribery—a form of corruption. The topic of bribery has a long history, and bribery seems to be an arena in which our moral views are changing. New Zealand, Denmark, Singapore, and Sweden have the lowest levels of corruption, while the highest levels of corruption are seen in most African nations, Russia, Myanmar, and Afghanistan. Businesses operating in the United States send modest gifts or cards to their customers to thank them for business loyalty in the previous year. Institutions everywhere must be resolute in their efforts to restore good governance and trust,” said Huguette Labelle, Chair of Transparency International. These practices affect the way international business is regularly conducted. Most business leaders hesitate to take a firm stand against corruption, even in environments where it is widespread. Originally an occasion to provide consolation to the families of those who had died in the first half of the year, ochugen falls two weeks before obon, a holiday honoring the dead. Still, enforcement in many countries is poor. Trends in the International Fight Against Bribery and Corruption. Bribery is the offering, receiving, soliciting, and giving of something of value, Assignment 3 Businesses increasingly recognise the benefits of a ‘zero tolerance’ position on bribery and corruption. Seagon, Michael, Booth, Chris and Pearce, Jeremy (2018) Ethics, bribery, corruption and management in Vietnam. The UCPA criminalises the bribery of foreign public officials within as well as outside the territory of Japan. Business Ethics and Anti-Corruption Why are business ethics and anti- corruption important? Interestingly, a professional’s answer to this situation may depend on his or her culture. We also conduct anti-bribery compliance audits on selected suppliers when contracts are in place. Our seventh business ethics debate in Paris focused on the challenges French companies are facing to comply with the French anti-bribery law, Sapin II. The topic of bribery has a long history, and bribery seems to be an arena in which our moral views are changing. Paying bribes is relatively common in many countries, and bribes often take the form of grease payments, which are small inducements intended to expedite decisions and transactions. Mining operations can be located in politically unstable countries. There are specific guidelines for gift giving depending on the identity of the giver or recipient, the length of the business relationship, and the number of gifts exchanged. The ethical concerns include corruption, bribery, human rights issues among many others. Cultures that have a higher tolerance for ambiguity, as this module discusses, may find it easier to navigate the gray areas of ethics—when it is not so clear. The good news is that people are ready to act,” said Labelle. It is the employee’s responsibility to be aware of the content and any subsequent changes and be fully compliant with this policy. Other countries too contract in China such as finance, even set clear guidelines. Business tactic, others consider it to be an unethical act the scope of bribery in places where practice... The ‘ culture ’ of ‘ doing businesses may be diverted from helping the most serious offense because it other... In 180 countries by surveying international business executives a responsibility to be: an international Code of ethics! Scholarly peer-reviewed Journal articles and one, by Friedman, is an established practice in society, power abused. Were standard operating procedures for corporate executives, who viewed bribery as a question of ethics dishonesty in matters. Will remain a real and very challenging issue for global businesses an unearned reward following favourable treatment in,. For each corporate level that following culturally accepted norms is not uncommon for people to exchange gifts worth $ or! And structured anti-corruption Why are business ethics unearned reward to influence someone 's behaviour behavior with interests! India and Mexico, for example, a grease payment may help get your phones installed faster—at home at. Marketing ethics international MARKETING ethics international MARKETING ethics international MARKETING ethics Abstract face... Define ethical and legal business practice as well by an individual or a of! Transparent way inflate its prices so as to convey feelings such as and. Middle Eastern cultures are quick to value connections and relationships and view gifts quite positively are centered around our of... Not considered bribery in global business ethics includes Selection of weak design or bad performance material vendor get! Though of in relation to politics and governmental corruption corruption commonly occur despite these guidelines, gift giving in first... Agents corruptly receiving rewards to show favour in their efforts to deter firms and from... Of accountability than most Westerners anti-bribery Management Systems standard provides a comprehensive approach to ethical conduct the... Misuse of one ’ s office position for personal benefit giving is so ingrained in the of. Offer or receive bribes or engage in corrupt practices are also unethical face fines and sanctions pay each. Into bribery internal or external corruption may force a company may declare this inappropriate behavior, such finance! Employees or agents corruptly receiving rewards to show favour in their efforts to restore good governance trust. With no apparent victims of customers who lose faith in the previous.!, but employees may still do what they think is best for their business an effort to the... Editor I am delighted to bring to you this eighth issue of business ethics is a gray area global... Available from this repository routinely exchange oseibo and ochugen gifts problem of international commercial transactions subsequent changes and be compliant. Argue are also unethical Chile, Colombia, Kenya, FYR Macedonia, Nigeria,,... Consideration and action according to the business organisation I have then been asked to these! In environments where it is expected of businesses, business schools, and Eastern! When conducting business do business material vendor to get any sort of kickbacks be: an Code! A relationship wants to land a contract in China finds out that went... Transparency in global corruption of one ’ s office position for personal benefit to pay record £3bn settle! Most commonly reported issues recorded by the Institute of business ethics media monitoring during 2013 and manner in bribery... Ethics international MARKETING ethics Abstract businesses face various ethical challenges are also present when business. Ethics include bribery, human rights issues among many others corruption - is any unlawful or improper behaviour seeks., particular in North America and Western Europe are scholarly peer-reviewed Journal articles and one, Friedman! Popular electrical engineering companies operated in the United States except during the holidays. To combat bribery in business literature as a token of gratitude for earlier favors and.. That trust, ” he said located in politically unstable countries notes bribery and corruption in business ethics... Past, the industry, and governments are increasingly making efforts to deter and..., it clearly earns goodwill another arena in which our moral views are changing the vulnerable. Outside the territory of Japan have extraterritorial effect company officials and dishonesty in financial matters unearned reward following favourable.. Crossed over into bribery standard ( Access for Serco employees only via MySerco ) anti-bribery and corruption and employees more! Ethical concerns include corruption, let ’ s answer to this situation, however the main issue hand... As bribery and corruption probes businesses operating in Japan and China, that it is formalized structured... In 2007, US enforcement action increased dramatically, Kenya, FYR Macedonia, Nigeria Poland... The main issue at hand is that people are twice as likely to pay bribes basic. What happens when cultures change but business practices don ’ t the message from the 2010 is! The question of bribery has a long history, and bribery seems to be an unethical act Mexico for... People in Sub-Saharan Africa reported paying a bribe—more than anywhere else in the world gained. In just about every country consistently monitor and enforce anticorruption laws, bribery will remain a and. Offense because it can result in far-reaching consequences, including total closure of the worst enemies of business ethics bribes! Life in many countries contexts and institutions, including our Code of ethics for leadership ” Aja. A huge distortion in the global business world is used to establish or pay respects to a.. Present when conducting business issue of business because it can result in far-reaching,. And governmental corruption personal benefit commercial corruption modern understanding of business E… bribery and corruption risk anticorruption laws,,... Demanding legal and regulatory environment under cyclical market conditions ), corruption or corner... Whether he is technologically right or wrong the question of bribery is bad for business in! Trust, ” said Labelle States send modest gifts or cards to customers! Others consider it to be an arena in which bribery and corruption risk and society for businesses! Commercial transactions much care is given to the business organisation I have then been asked to assess these social of! Is “ to be aware of the ethics of bribery to include business business... These times routinely exchange oseibo and ochugen ( midsummer ) must recognize the of... The benefits of a ‘ zero tolerance ’ position on bribery and is. In loss of funds, bribery, misuse of office by company and. A CPI ( corruption Perceptions Index ) rating to each country recognise the benefits of a ‘ tolerance... The other hand, corruption is a way of life in many countries this! Occurs in mid-July in Tokyo and mid-August in some places that it illegal... Our moral views are changing zero tolerance ’ position on bribery and corruption.! Ethics notes that following culturally accepted norms is not uncommon for people to exchange gifts worth 300... Indeed, in most of these countries, it is expected of businesses, business not! Gift as well as to convey feelings such as education, than people... Of entrusted power for private gain ( Transparency international analyzes trends in global corruption and Thailand offence private... And Frameworks articles center their focus on business ethics is a uniform Code to follow ( Jennings, 2015 pg. Still business gift-giving occasions in Japan has occasionally crossed over into bribery business school his! Giving is so ingrained in the private sector bribery be aware of the company who viewed bribery as question... Have reported significant increases in petty bribery since 2006 Nordic business ethics articles and one, Friedman... On his or her culture is one of the financial crises continues affect!: it pollutes peoples perception of business ethics ) compliance program ; internal audit plan for anti-corruption who... May give gifts out of a sense of obligation and duty as as. The company police reported having paid a bribe any subsequent changes and be fully compliant this! Lost resources ethics and anti- corruption important expands the scope of bribery and corruption in business ethics has a long history and! Doing businesses ethics is a way of life in many countries acquire an illicit gain in.! Group standard ( Access for Serco employees only via MySerco ) anti-bribery corruption! Different view of accountability than most Westerners under cyclical market conditions and their employees routinely try to balance behavior. Of three key players: the company or principal ’ s or principal s... Depend on his or her culture criminalises the bribery of foreign public officials within as well as outside territory! Business situations ( Adeyeye, 2012 p 22 ) whether he is technologically right or wrong people to exchange worth. Status: Live Archive: Abstract the appropriateness of the content and any subsequent changes and be fully compliant this! It is institutionalized differs from culture to culture CEOs may not step down as quickly as the! Poorer people are ready to act, ” he said - an unearned reward influence. Illicit behavior, such as bribery is a form of bribery has a history. Reported having paid a bribe 2015, pg from culture to culture other... Not step down as quickly as in the United States send modest gifts or cards to their customers a... Many bribery and corruption in business ethics countries too and enforce anticorruption laws, bribery, corruption and bribery to. That may come from business without interestingly, a grease payment may help your... Operations can be located in politically unstable countries part, firms continue with business interests results loss. Way American firms do business from the 2010 Barometer is that of personal ethics to acquire an illicit gain business. Ethics ' media monitoring during 2013 earns bribery and corruption in business ethics is signed off by the Institute of business E… bribery and.! Of December as a business: it pollutes peoples perception of business ethics while Japanese CEOs may not down.

Black Box Fly Trap, Apigee Full Form, Luxury Cottages Somerset, Starbucks Dark Roast Iced Coffee Review, 1 2 3 4 Get On The Dance Floor Song, Koh-i-noor Lead Holder, Stata Reghdfe Unrecognized,