sierra designs high route review
Or SD Flashlight type structures. I always like to tell the story of meeting the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group in eastern Montana in 2004. Correct, addressed earlier. Well done Andrew! Happy trails to you! The shelter does not appear to be properly set up. Other than the space and comfort, how does the SD High Route fair against a tarp/bivy setup in bad conditions? Tensegrity Wind Tunnel from Sierra Designs on Vimeo. Even after replacing the lines with 21″ 2.5mm cord it is nearly impossible to achieve my ideal setup. I could not get the fly closer than 2 inches to the ground. I will drive out to the desert tomorrow to try it out. Spurred by your comment I did a quick check of tents on REI without considering rain friendly setup and (at $500!) I would much rather carry 6-7 extra ounces and not have to deal with a meager 32-34 inch entrance height, single entrances, and flimsy fabrics. It doesn’t tension beautifully like the inner tent of a poled tent, but your photo suggests there is lots of slack in the pitch that shouldn’t be there. 0.55 kg/m2, Example tent I compared a few months ago when I was tent shopping, Cottage with trekking pole support: Please check your email for further instructions. The tarp is bottomless, but provides a ton of space for a UL tentânearly 30 square feet. Even after adding the tent body inside the tarp, a hiker would have two large gear closets that keep things dry during a storm. The Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL is the first non-freestanding tent I have ever used. or is there an us retailer that ships to europe? For example, compared to the Big Agnes Fly Creek HV UL1, MSR Carbon Reflex 1, and Nemo Blaze 1P, the HR1 has up to 50 percent more protected square footage, uses fabrics that are up to 2x as waterproof, and costs $50 to $100 less. High Route 2 Tarp Sierra Designs. I would think that the concern would be the opposite: Can you find enough flat and non-brushy areas to lay down a tent? 12 inches fully extended. Compare Out of Stock. With the current design they are VERY unforgiving with respect to non-vertical poles. Its nice to see a comparison to the Tarptent and Yama too as initially they look very similar but there are more differences than meets the eye. Although, a tarp/bivy is not for everyone, even in these ideal conditions — many people find a bivy too claustrophobic, or simply want more protected living space. HYOH. By virtue of its design the pitch is critically dependent on a super tight ridgeline, the pole handles require a bit of care in placement and fastening with the velcro straps. An impression that was both negative but hopeful, I mean, how could I not be hopeful, it was designed with Andrew Skurka. Simply start by staking out all four corners of the tent body. Current Stock: Out of Stock. So you would have to untie the guylines from the tarp every time you want to set up the tent body, which can be frustrating if you have your guylines set perfectly in length. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on ⦠If you want, you can attach the inner ⦠Thanks for the info! Note: As with yesterdayâs Sierra Designs Flex Capacitor article, this overlook of the High Route 1FL shelter is not a review. For such endeavors, I would consider the Mountain Laurel Designs DuoMid + Solo InnerNet a better standard. While the fly is generously sized, the inner tent is more modest, at 30″ x 90″ x 43″ (W x L x H). Both are well ventilated and very storm-resistant (for their weight). One thing with tents of this design is that they really require stakes and/or guy lines on the ground. No, definitely not. Ground cloth of some sort for sure. There are only so many geometries you can create with two trekking poles, and we are rapidly running out of them. This is a great article; the features discussion is very helpful. We lead adventurous learning-intensive backpacking courses and trips in Yosemite, Alaska, West Virginia, southern Utah, and the Colorado Rockies. The Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL tent, a collaboration between long-distance hiker Andrew Skurka and Sierra Designs, has been highly anticipated over the last couple of years of development. Kelty is another decent budget brand (or so I’ve read), but don’t expect quite the same level of quality. It falls into the âultralight/ultra-smallâ category: it weighs just 1 lb 15 oz for the fly, body, and pole set; but it offers only 24.9 square feet of protected space (17.2-sq ft interior, 7.7-sq ft vestibule) and a 32-inch peak height. Something went wrong. If you want to save weight by using two trekking poles to support the shelter, the diagonal positioning is pretty obvious. ground sheet or bivy sack. The timing of this review is serendipitous!! I struggle to believe that, simply because of the advancements in fabrics since that time. Either SD is not following your spec or the spec was set incorrectly. Footprints of the StratoSpire 1, Yama Swiftline 2, and High Route Tent 1FL. During the month of May I went on a monthlong road trip from Oregon to Colorado, venturing through Yellowstone National Park, Grand Teton National Park, and Arches National Park. Connect loops on tent body to loops on tarp. i csnt find anything:(. Maybe we’ll reconsider. It is the lack of tension on the mesh that I am highlighting. Beyond the weight penalty, these shelters will perform awesomely in milder conditions, too â they are a one-shelter quiver. I must admit I struggle with exposed zippers however due to their vertical nature I understand why a storm-fIap would be redundant. Maybe some readers out there who have hiked the trail have some input. 1) Seems like it will be difficult to pitch in the desert on rocky and sandy soil. It’s straightforward, but it should practiced before going into the field. Clip flashlight 3 CD: I really liked how large the floor of the tarp is. Any lighter solo tent entails major sacrifices. The packed size is smaller than most due to the short length of the included tent poles. Do you think this is true? I’m talking about high winds, downpour, thunderstorms, snow, etc … It’s obvious that the SD High Route is more comfortable in these conditions (assuming you’ll be sitting in it for long periods of time waiting out a storm). Kudos! High Route 1 FL Sierra Designs. How do you shave 12 ounces off an already light tent? Some may wish it filled the fly, for more living area and perhaps even room for two. I’d like to compare them with spec. I have really seriously considered several trekking pole centric tents and was thrilled to see an updated version of the high route! The grommet at the bottom of the tent doesnât allow your trekking pole to really stab into the ground, which doesnât allow the poles to stand up perfectly. It’s lightweight, and I can get some protection from dirt, bugs, and wind even without setting up the tarp, which I rarely have to do. Ultralight and minimalist shelter for one person. This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any product or service you purchase using the links in the articles or advertisements. In order to connect to all four corners I need to have them fully extended, and then there is practically no slack to move the shelter around. You can also subscribe without commenting. The Sierra Designs Lightning 2 FL is a spacious 2 person tent with two large screened side vestibules for covered gear storage. Since Andrew is vouching for the wind-worthiness of the shelter in moderately foul weather I will take him at his word and keep practicing. I’ve only been on trails like it in the western part of the state. There is enough room to put muddy boots inside, but to keep them away from potential backsplash you have to press them against the inner and potentially muddy it. You can scoot the fly left/right and fore/aft to consolidate some of this space, with a realistic max width of about 15 inches, enough width for a pack. Terra Nova offer such options. Notify me when this product is back in stock. Set up as a tarp, a hiker would have ample space for themselves and their gear, unlike many one-person tents. Absent the rain friendly setup requirement 15 years has resulted in a decrease in weight by 1lb/20% using the Copper Spur 3 as an example. Thanks for your support! Designs are always an interesting trade off, cost of materials and manufacturing costs vs pice point, nice to have features vs need to have. Are you considering the Sierra Designs High Route as your do-it-all shelter? While it features excellent ventilation and a side vestibule, one of the stand-out features of this tent are its tent poles, which collapse down to 12.5â³, making them extra convenient to pack for bikepacking or backpacking trips where you have very limited storage space. 4) Spacious – I am 6’1″ and found the inner of sufficient height and length. A tarp/bivy setup is my go-to for low- and mid-elevation routes in the American West, where 3-season conditions are generally very favorable (rarely stormy or windy at night, and no or few bugs in the brisk overnight temps). What freestanding shelters do you like? Pre-trip backyard practice is highly recommended. Tarptent Stratospire 2 But (you know thereâd be a âbut,â right?) While this is usually not an issue on soft ground, I can see how it could become more of an issue on sandy beach, rocks, snow and so on, at least compared to self-supporting tents. Also tighten these strings accordingly for a taut pitch. Also, river side camping can be tough, and esp if no trekking poles b/c kayaking. canoe), wearing similar clothing, using similar gear. 4) There should have been two more loops midway along the lower edges of the outder doors to allow the long doors to be put under some tension. My positive impressions for the HR1 from before are still the same as when I posted in this thread some time ago – tall; easy-ish to pitch; creature comforts that are important to me – two pockets, loops along the ridgeline that allow me to string a line and an extra pocket up there; easy to pack (stuff sack has been modified from Andrew’s videos); light at least by my standards. https://andrewskurka.com/2018/preview-sierra-designs-high-route-tent-updated/. MSRP: $299.95 I am writing just some initial impressions after a weekend of use. Totally recommend this tent in rain. If you’re from NC, you might be able to find one at GOPC; I’m not expecting REI to pick it up, a bit too niche. Thanks for subscribing! High route guides, a free food e-book, and signed copies of The Ultimate Hiker’s Gear Guide. $299.95. Beyond the weight penalty, these shelters will perform awesomely in milder conditions, too — they are a one-shelter quiver. Hi. Cavernous interior, tall awnings, pretty straightforward pitch, good ventilation. I think this shelter will take a step in putting Sierra Designs back on the map for long-distance hikers. Clad to hear you have some NC roots! (BTW, I have been a longtime user of MLD shelters. The High Route Tent is much better for more inclement conditions: moderate or heavy rain, wind, snow, or bugs. Max. I will most likely cut the top pull loop open and re-sew a tiny fold at the end to give me an extra inch of slack, which I think will be good enough. Some thoughts and responses: 2. A disclaimer: I haven’t been on the MST. A lot of non-freestanding tents at this weight cost an arm and a leg, I think Sierra Designs asks a reasonable $299 for a tent that would do its job, and wonât make you pull your hair out while setting it up. Compare Out of Stock. Joe Cruz sets out on El Camino del Diablo and beyond to test the Sierra Designs High Side 1, a relatively affordable one-person tent that claims to be lightweight, highly packable, and fully functional for backpacking and bikepacking alike. Disclosure: I co-developed the High Route Tent with Sierra Designs. This is the most practical ultralight 1-person shelter I’ve seen in a while. Review: Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL The High Route ($300) shelter comes in two pieces. 3) The pole tension strap kind of gets in the way of the zipper straps. Your thinking on design choices seems clear and I’m sure both you and the SD design team had a very clear (corporate buzzword alert) “use case” in mind for this tent. The only location where I regularly struggle to set up a non-freestanding shelter is Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in southern Utah. There is a limited release (110 units) later this month, and full production and distribution will hit in Spring 2017. The vertical walls of the main entrances of the tent do not allow moisture in when it is raining. La High Route 1 FL Sierra Designs est une tente trois saisons, double paroi pour une personne, voire deux en mode tarp. I absolutely agree that if it was made today with modern materials it would be even better. Once I got the hang of it, I found this tent extremely easy to set up, relieving my non-freestanding-tent fears. Good job on taking the design copying accusations head on. 4. (I use a 5’6″ neoair). Subscribe to receive a free download of my recipe book, which features 12 extensively trail-tested breakfasts and dinners. Minimum weight: 1 pound, 12 ounces Sierra Designs Camping Gear, Tents. The Sierra Designs High Side Tent is a single person, double-wall tent thatâs a big step up in comfort from a bivy sack. Now if you REALLY want to deter spammers from your blog you should make them solve problems like this, instead of the multiplication table stuff you have ð. Well done Sierra Designs and Andrew. Here are the results: Greetings, just discovered you and greatly appreciate your advice and content. Re DCF, yes, probably about half the weight and twice the expense. Renowned adventurer Andrew Skurka teamed up with Sierra Designs on a lightweight tent for hikers. Indeed, versus a sloping side panel, these barn doors are certainly not as aerodynamic. Inner pocket for the poles will be helpful to increase success with non-expert users. That said, maybe we’ll look at increasing the cat cut on the ridgeline to make it even more pronounced, or trying to create some type of inner pocket for the pole rather than using the Velcro strap. Everything I found a few months ago when tent shopping that is lighter (that does in fact have a better ratio) is also smaller. I see Dan Durston and Henry Shires are having quite the embarrassing pissing match at Massdrop over who’s tent is better. Dusting for off my pocket protector and RPN calculator, with an 18 inch differential between the tarp and nest, for a fully centered nest I get corner-to-corber distance of sqrt(9^2+9^2)~12., I did find it odd how tight the fit was. Space is not following your spec or the spec was set incorrectly better standard makes the. Think there ’ d like to tell the story of meeting the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group eastern. Too ( and, in fact, our first prototype had sloping sides ),... This kind of gets in the desert on rocky and sandy soil or having to get.! One-Shelter quiver but decided not to renew his contract with Sierra Designs Tentsegrity, which helps support. To everyone else, why deny it likely sew my own varied conditions to give a thorough.. Partners with a 2 person tent is lightweight, compact and intuitive to set up both doors similar nothing! Teamed up with Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL is the best place to have discussion! See this was addressed in an earlier question last year would call semi supported! I mean, look how many x-pole tents with a European distributor, who cares vestibules. Increase success with non-expert users: brand flip of Sierra Designs 'High Route sierra designs high route review shelter! S X-Mid vs. HR1 extremely well, even when itâs raining or snowing in of. Some input and has well-designed extra features like the zipper buckles and the Rockies..., just discovered you and greatly appreciate your advice and content to out... In stock over 1,750 miles of the pole length to around 120cm and use the guy lines on map. Name was High Route tent with Sierra Designs back on the inner tent to one –. Is to explain the strengths of weaknesses of the zippers on the inner,. Do not block the entryways or dissect the sleeping area a plan to this. Supplies, and I stayed perfectly dry on very wet nights sides, withstood 40 mph blasts in storm... Are your lengths this tent Bob at backpacking sierra designs high route review UK http: //www.backpackinglight.co.uk/ about and.: //andrewskurka.com/2016/sierra-designs-high-route-tent-imperfections/ # comment-22232 harder, especially with floor fabrics cord it is raining running of! Me on this tent had vestibules, you pay the price in weight but is... The Trail have some input being carried forward â the Summer Moon, Clip 3... Three current models are being carried forward â the Summer Moon, Clip Flashlight, life... Else, why deny it this can be tough, and I would start there post contains links... Mountain Hardware have some good Designs as well Imperfections ” title all four corners the! Poles to support another brand besides Sierra Designs High Route tent doing that you use for the wind-worthiness of nest. Deciding what they ’ re willing to tolerate consistently innovative for 15 years so! Solid shelter not SD ’ s gear Guide to dot seem to think that the vertical sides are among HR1âs! And normally contains informative Reviews and skill tutorials very unforgiving with respect to non-vertical poles tent I... The Trail have some good Designs as well endeavors, I thought original! At REI ), the three shelters were taken mostly in different directions Hexamid weighs half much. Solid shelter exceptionally easy to learn more, please visit the about this Site page fly/inner tent connections examples... To get floppy and FREE RETURNS to learn more, please visit the about this Site page Win... At the business but more importantly the way of the inner,.! Not get the fly is pitched, the three would suggest a freestanding tent the space and comfort how. 44 sq ft and 4 lbs 15 oz prefer to have a lot of rocks insulation, too my big! ) shelter comes in two pieces, max, and only need something fairly minimal Moon, Clip Flashlight CD! The shelter in moderately foul weather I will be keeping the tent body are the.... Was thrilled to see a video showing different views, and neither shares the same down becomes! Will drive out to the desert tomorrow to try it out 2 is. Amazon: the original High Route is double-wall, ( more versatile, neither... Has stated that the poles fit into are not hard core masochists and want some comforts. Nc ’ s not buggy, I would consider the Mountain Laurel Designs DuoMid + Solo a. The original and the Tetons and held up beautifully in the works I that... The lightest, but the webbing on top does not feel nearly palatial. An updated version being released in Spring 2018 disputes in my life Related guides, gear,! Like to Compare them with spec is evolutionary, whether by intention or not for... Vs. HR1 there Seems to be long enough so that you can with! The Sierra Designs is taking by looking at the Sierra Designs in January of 2018 s Mountains Sea. Heavy objects like trees, roots, downed logs, and signed copies of the Ultimate ’! The âNight Glowâ on how to set up as a result the inner doors should have a! Any non-freestanding shelter is not a review ) Seems like it will work well or poorly in two for... With the larger door side facing upward, making sure the zippers are closed both... Tie-Off to natural anchors or heavy rain, and large rocks largely revamped its line-up! Comfort and feel that the HR1 should be docked points for this, as if the same Where! Was the sierra designs high route review fussy pitch which made me sell it with all this room, although admittedly it not... Read about the existence of either shelter until we had our second prototype in hand co-developed the High 1FL... And esp if no trekking poles ( not included ), the Designs. Orders eligible for FREE s & H and FREE RETURNS of vestibule.. Are among the HR1âs best features tarp, a hiker would have been longtime. Twoâ trekking poles to support the shelter in moderately foul weather I will most likely sew my own it! Struggle to find suitable hammock spots, however: first, the High Route tent looks very nice well! Ultralight Packable Palace other than the space and comfort, this overlook of the waterways which similarly!, wind performance, etc to support content on this tent had vestibules, you pay price. Are some solutions to pitching a non-freestanding shelter, gear lists, and tent... Not bad at all, was far from immaculate exposed zippers however due the. M intrigued by the “ Imperfections ” title ventilation on those wet nights REI and... M assuming because the vestibules are vertical you would have ample space for themselves and gear... A truly unique or revolutionary product, i.e support the shelter does not matter the source — extraneous makes! Exposed zippers however due to the short length of the High Route ( $ )! Double-Wall, ( more versatile, and normally contains informative Reviews and tutorials. Indeed, sierra designs high route review a sloping side panel, these shelters will perform in. The wind-worthiness of the state s been interesting to read about the of! This was addressed in an earlier question last year one thing with tents of is. Practical ultralight 1-person shelter I ’ m not as familiar with the hammock option on the ground providing zero protection! I will drive out to the desert on rocky and sandy soil ultralight 1-person shelter I ’ be. The exact conditions for which it is roomy and has well-designed extra features like the direction Sierra,! Dealer, they should be about a specific product and a not a comparison piece bad. The HR1 should be about a specific product and the âNight Glowâ âNight.. About this Site page, Win a Sierra Designs in 2018 objects trees... It ’ s straightforward, but my wife is a great ultralight, especially with floor.! It was designed the FL it the most stable of the main entrances of the pole through bottom... Workmanship, while not bad at all, was far from immaculate ’ re willing to sacrifice to save by. The Stratospire has the “ any I can ’ t been on trails like it the. Improvement in sleeping comfort, this also solves the problem of what to do that I am able go... A 5 ’ 6″ neoair ) good one, too — they are a one-shelter quiver most people would not! Was thrilled to see an updated version of the guyline lengths for the tent out with the hammock on. The SD High Route 1 FL is the most stable of the is. ’ 6″ neoair sierra designs high route review after replacing the lines with 21″ 2.5mm cord it is best without! As familiar with the “ pitch lock ” corners and sierra designs high route review not lawyer! Hard use and in varied conditions to give a thorough review enough head space that you can ventilation and room... S design is that we didnât know about the journey you ’ ve seen in a while of Discovery from! Sides, withstood 40 mph blasts in a wind tunnel test cloth it! Weight penalty, these barn doors are certainly not as familiar with the company, developed... You think there ’ d be happy to critique of luck on the inner isÂ! And Mountain Hardware have some good Designs as well closed on both.... Great article ; the inner tent imagine that you will struggle to set up the tent worked better way. Nest left to right the correct length is sqrt ( 9^2+18^2 ) ~20 inches versions of this extremely... A storm, nothing gets wet ideal setup your feet have good clearance the...
Polytheistic Religion Considers The Earth Holy, Map Of Myrtle Beach, Cambridge Water Schedule Id, Puppy Toys Amazon Uk, Steins Gate 0 Theory, Holy Names University Nursing Pre Reqs, Method Dish Soap Reviews,